← All guides

Your Insurer Is Quietly Raising Your Premium

Auto and home insurance premiums rise 6–12% a year at renewal, even for drivers with no claims. The increase assumes you will not call. A 15-minute phone call with a competing quote unwinds most of it.

The creep

Every insurer files rate increases with state insurance commissioners. Those filings get rubber-stamped as long as the overall loss ratio justifies them, which it always does once you average in catastrophic events in other states. The result: a driver in Tennessee with a clean record pays more each year because California had wildfires.

Insurers expect high customer inertia. Internal data shows that 60%+ of customers will renew without shopping, which is why the pricing works — the 40% who do shop pay less than the 60% who don't.

The 15-minute call

Before you call your current insurer, get two competing quotes from different insurers. This takes 10 minutes and changes the nature of every subsequent call.

1. Pull a quote from a direct writer (GEICO or Progressive) with your exact coverage.
2. Pull a quote from an independent agent comparison tool (PolicyGenius, Insurify) with the same coverage.
3. Call your current insurer. Say: "I got a quote from [X] at [$Y]. What can you do?"

Without the competing quote, you are asking for a favor. With it, you are presenting a business decision.

"I just got a quote from [competitor] for the same coverage at [$X]. I've been a customer for [Y years]. I'd rather stay, but the price difference is significant. Can you match it or come close?"

The hidden fees

• Installment fee ($4–$8/month): Charged if you pay monthly instead of in full. Pay semi-annually to eliminate.
• Policy fee ($15–$50): One-time admin fee per 6-month policy period. Usually not waivable but worth knowing about.
• SR-22 filing fee ($15–$25): If you had a DUI or license suspension. One-time fee per state filing.
• Paper bill fee ($1–$2/month): Go paperless to remove.
• Late payment fee ($10–$15): Set auto-pay even if you do not want to. Missed payment can also trigger a non-renewal.

When bundling saves money (and when it doesn't)

Multi-policy discounts are 5–25% depending on the insurer. They are real, but they apply to that insurer's base rate, not a market-wide rate. If your current bundle is with a company whose unbundled rates are already 20% above market, the bundle discount only brings you back to roughly market price — not a deal.

Rule of thumb: bundle is worth keeping if your bundled total is cheaper than the best unbundled auto quote plus the best unbundled home quote. Get both separately and add them. Only then decide.

Common questions