← All guides

Modem and Router Rental Fees: The $180/Year Opt-Out

Most internet providers charge $14 to $18 a month for the modem on your shelf. You can buy a compatible one for $80 to $150, return theirs, and have the fee removed within one or two billing cycles.

The short version

Most internet service providers charge a monthly rental fee for the modem or combined modem/router (gateway) they provide. The fee typically ranges from $14 to $18 per month, or $168 to $216 per year.

This is one of the most consistently removable fees on a home internet bill. In most cases, you can buy your own compatible modem for $80 to $150, return the provider's equipment, and have the rental fee removed from your bill within one or two billing cycles. The equipment typically pays for itself within 6 to 12 months.

This guide explains how the fee works, what equipment is compatible with major providers, and how the process of switching to owned equipment typically goes.

What the fee is

When you sign up for home internet service, most providers ship you a modem, router, or combined gateway device. It sits on your shelf, connects to the provider's network, and provides your home WiFi. The provider charges a monthly rental fee for this equipment.

Common fees by provider:

• Comcast Xfinity: $15/month "xFi Gateway" rental
• Spectrum: included for modem; WiFi router rental around $5-7/month
• Cox: $14/month panoramic WiFi gateway
• AT&T Fiber: $10/month gateway rental
• Verizon Fios: $17/month Fios Gateway rental
• Optimum: $10-14/month Smart Router

Fees and equipment policies change over time. Check your provider's current rate card for accuracy.

The rental arrangement is profitable for providers. After 12 months of rental at $15/month, a customer has paid $180 for a device that typically costs the provider $40-60 wholesale. After three years, the customer has paid more than $500. The equipment itself may be used for five or more years and rented to multiple customers over its lifetime.

Buying your own equipment

All major cable and fiber ISPs are required by federal law (47 U.S.C. § 549) to allow customers to use their own compatible equipment. The FCC has reaffirmed this right repeatedly.

What this means in practice:

• You can purchase a compatible modem from Amazon, Best Buy, or direct from a manufacturer
• The provider must provision your equipment on their network
• The rental fee must come off your bill once you return their equipment
• The provider cannot refuse service based on you using your own equipment (though they may limit certain features like in-home WiFi management apps)

Compatibility matters. Not every modem works with every provider. Providers publish "approved device" lists. The most common compatible modem brands:

• Motorola (MB series, MG series gateway)
• Netgear (Nighthawk CM, CAX series)
• ARRIS (Surfboard SB and SBG series)
• TP-Link (Archer series)

For cable internet, look for DOCSIS 3.1 compatibility as a baseline (DOCSIS 4.0 for gigabit+ plans). For fiber, check your provider's approved device list, compatibility is tighter.

The process, step by step

What consumers typically report:

1. Check your provider's approved device list. Each provider publishes one. Make sure the modem you buy is on it and supports your plan's speed tier.
2. Buy a compatible modem or gateway. Budget $80-100 for a modem-only device (if you have a separate router). Budget $150-250 for a modem/router/WiFi gateway combo. The combo is simpler but has a shorter upgrade cycle.
3. Activate the new equipment. Most providers have self-service activation through an app or web portal. Some require a phone call to customer service to pair your modem's MAC address to your account.
4. Confirm internet is working on the new equipment. Before proceeding, make sure your connection is stable.
5. Return the provider's equipment. Most providers accept returns at UPS stores (for Xfinity) or directly at provider retail stores. Keep the return receipt. Without it, you can be billed for unreturned equipment ($150-300 charge).
6. Verify the rental fee is removed from your next bill. If it still appears, call customer service with your return receipt number. This is where most issues happen. The rental fee sometimes persists through one extra billing cycle.

When it's not worth doing

A few cases where keeping the rental equipment might make sense:

• You have unreliable ISP service and value having them handle equipment issues
• Your provider includes equipment "free" (Spectrum includes modem rental in many plans)
• You're on a short-term lease where you'll move in under 12 months
• You're on a DSL or fiber plan with limited compatible equipment options
• Your ISP has a promotional rate that specifically bundles equipment for a period

For most customers on cable internet (Xfinity, Spectrum, Cox, Optimum), buying your own equipment pays back within a year.

A sample interaction

If you need to call to have the rental fee removed after returning equipment, one approach:

"Hi, I returned my [Xfinity xFi Gateway / Fios Gateway / etc.] on [date] at [UPS store / provider store]. My return receipt number is [number]. I'm using my own modem now. I see the rental fee is still on my current bill. Can you remove it and process any prorated credit?"

This is a simple administrative call, not a negotiation. Reps have full authority to remove the fee once equipment is returned.

If the rep claims they can't see the return:

"The return was processed at [location] on [date]. I have the receipt. Can you check the return system or transfer me to equipment services?"

Keep the return receipt until the fee clears and stays off for at least two billing cycles.

If you'd rather not handle equipment yourself

Some bill-negotiation services handle equipment-related savings as part of broader bill reductions, though they don't typically do the physical equipment purchase for you. BillShark and Rocket Money may include "recommend you buy your own modem" as part of their negotiation.

We have affiliate relationships with both. If you use them through our links, we earn a commission.

Common questions

A note on scope

This is consumer information based on FCC rules, provider disclosures, and documented consumer experience. Equipment compatibility and provider policies change. Before purchasing equipment, verify current compatibility with your specific plan and provider. This is not technical or financial advice.